Thursday, 7 March 2013

A2 LL - 3 WAY COMPARISONS COMMENTARY - THE BASICS

Below is a table containing the main ways of comparing and contrasting the three texts


FEATURE
DETAIL
COMMENT
EXAMPLE
Audience


Who is the target audience?
For example: public, private, general, exclusive
Purpose
Primary
What is the dominating purpose of the text? Be general

But also be specific
For example: inform, question, instruct, exclaim

For example: advise, order, proclaim, interrogate

Secondary
All texts have more than one purpose. Identify a secondary general purpose and then be specific.
See above
Genre
Writing style
Identify the different genres of writing within each text
For example: descriptive, dialogue, narrative, anecdotal

Writing technique
Identify the different language and literary features used in each text. Ensure that for each text you identify literary and linguistic features
For example: linguistic – grammar, syntax, lexis, register

For example: literary – imagery, phonology, rhetoric

For example: spoken features - fluency and non fluency features

Click here for more details on these analytical frameworks.
Theme
Presentation
Comment on the presentation of the theme that links the three texts together. Focus on similarities and or differences
Identify comparative characteristics - abstract/concrete, general/specific

Attitude
Comment on the underpinning attitudes, values, assumptions the narrator adopts towards the theme.
For example: sympathetic, unsympathetic, angry, tolerant